Shop Now At Market Day
Most Popular Products
Top-Rated Products
Pumpkin Pie
(4)
French Silk Pie
(12)
Customer Reviews for Lemon Supreme Pie
This product is no longer available. Continue shopping at Market Day.
Lemon Supreme Pie
Philadelphia Cream Cheese blended with whipped cream and lemon filling. Thaw & serve.
Average Customer Rating:
(20 Reviews) 20
Rating Snapshot (20 reviews)
5 stars
19
4 stars
0
3 stars
0
2 stars
1
1 star
0
19 out of 20(95%)customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Lemon Supreme Pie
Review 1 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
best lemon pie ever
Date:October 26, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile, flaky crust
Flaky crust, creamy filling and nice tart lemon flavor. Hope they will have it available again.
otter
Location: Indpls., IN
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 55-65
Share this review:
Review 2 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Delicious!!
Date:April 17, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile, delicious
I love lemon anything, and this is one of Market Day's best. I took to a church function and it was gone fast. Glad to see it back on the order form. Great to have in freezer for surprise guests, or need something to take to family/friend outings/parties.. Just thaw and enjoy!!
YoungGrandma721
Location: Hoffman Estates, Il.
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: Only Me
Age: 55-65
Share this review:
Review 3 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Delicious!
Date:November 28, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Good Texture
We had this pie after Thanksgiving dinner and it was a nice change from the typical pumpkin pie we usually have. Loved the cream cheese layer with the tart lemon filling. It made a delicious combination! The presentation was beautiful too. I'll be ordering this one again!
CentralIllinoisMom
Location: Central, Il
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 25-34
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 4 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
The BEST Tasting Pie!
Date:October 31, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
Lemon Supreme Pie is our favorite! I was so glad to see Marketday bring it back for their customers. We have ordered this pie for many holiday meals. Everyone enjoys it. You don't know what you're missing If you've never tasted it.
brabsont
Location: Ohio
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 5 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Great
Date:February 17, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, Healthy, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile, smooth, no mess
This is a Super Pie.
Why everytime you get a Great product you don't have it so it can be ordered again?
If I can't buy it again, I have to go get it from another place.
sky545454
Location: Garden City, Michigan
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: Over 65
Share this review:
Review 6 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Very Pleased!
Date:November 27, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, Good Texture, Versatile
Cons: plastic top didn't fit properly; wouldn't close
I couldn't have been happier with this pie! it was a huge hit with my entire family! The lemon curd was excellent and the cheesecake layer offered just the "right" amount of sweetness! The crust was nothing "special" but was not bad--it certainly didn't distract from the filling. I would definately order again!
hsmc11
Location: Lexington, KY
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 7 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
BEST LEMON PIE OF ALL TIME!!!
Date:November 21, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
Absolutely LOVE, LOVE, this pie. I'm so glad to be able to order it from Market Day for the Holidays every year!!! Truly the best tasting lemon pie you'll ever have!!!
shimmie
Location: Somerset, NJ
Cooking Style: Gourmet
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 55-65
Share this review:
Review 8 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
AMAZING!
Date:October 17, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
Cons: only available once a year
I was reluctant to try this product because I am not a fan of lemon pies at all. I believe they are way too thin and the flavor is too "artificial".
NOT THIS PIE! Ever since I tasted Market Day's Lemon Supreme Pie...I'M HOOKED! My only wish is that the pies were offered more than once a year. We're now onto trying other pies, but I just cannot get this flavor out of my mind (and taste buds. Lol)...its that good. Very rich and real quality ingredients in it. Nothing I've tasted has come close.
Just defrost and try to share. :)
MrsB
Location: IL
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 9 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Great
Date:June 2, 2011
This was really yummy. I would order again. Delicious.
busybee
Location: WI
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 10 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
GREAT LEMON FLAVOR
Date:April 6, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile
I loved this pie,being single and live alone this pie is huge so I cut portions for single servings, and froze it I had pie for months.
MsKitty
Location: CHICAGO
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Only Me
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 11 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Best Ever
Date:March 17, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
If you love lemon meringue and cream cheese, this is the best ever combination. Took it to work, everyone loved it. Especially the lemon cake and anything with cream cheese lovers.
Indybound
Location: Indianapolis, IN
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 12 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
We loved Lemon Supreme Pie
Date:December 23, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep
My family and relatives love the lemon supreme pie. I ordered it everytime it is available around Thanksgiving. You should have it for Christmas as well as on the list of desserts every month.
Woogie
Location: Harrison Twp., MI
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 13 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Great for the hoildays
Date:December 2, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
Cons: lid won't stay on after it is opened
I bought this pie for Thanksgiving and wow is it ever delicious..my daughter's love the cream cheese in the bottom and the tart lemon on top..I am ordering another one for Christmas..Thank you to whomever came up with this idea of a pie!!!
Iammomoftwo
Location: Geneva,Oh
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 14 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Never buying again
Date:December 2, 2010
Pros: Easy Prep
Cons: Poor Flavor
The filling was what I would refer to as "average," tart lemon pudding over no-bake cheesecake. However, I will not buy this again simply because of the crust, it was bland, dry, and tasted incomplete somehow, it was difficult to decide exactly what the flavor of it was. The pie filling was pretty good once the pie was turned upside down on the plate and we pulled off the crust. Without a doubt the family agreed that the crust was so awful that when it was left on it ruined the taste of the entire pie.
PurpleDragonfly
Location: IL
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 15 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
BitterSweet
Date:December 1, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
The title is in reference to December being the "last month" for this delicious pie. I purchased this pie in November to serve as dessert after Thanksgiving dinner. I was torn between this pie and the deep dish apple pie; glad I chose this one. I thought this pie would be tangy from the lemon or too sweet from the cream cheese, but to my surprise it balances out perfectly. The crust is light and adds a nice foundation to the cream cheese and lemon. My entire family loved this pie and while it is a bit rich...I am ordering another this month.
flynailz
Location: Euclid, Ohio
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 16 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Date:November 28, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
Bought this pie for Thanksgiving and could not have enough of it. Everyone absolutely LOVED IT!!!! The best pie I've had by far.
Lichy
Location: New Jersey
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 17 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
MMMM MMMMM
Date:October 28, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, High Quality
Every month I look first in the desserts section for this pie and am always disappointed... Until now!! Welcome back, my pie!!
RnMom
Location: Ohio
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 18 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Thank you
Date:October 25, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, High Quality
Thank you for bringing this pie back. I like to slice mine frozen and put it back in the freezer, then I can take out only as much as I need.
Thanks again for bringing it back.
Thanks again for bringing it back.
Anonymous
Location: Chicago, Il
Cooking Style: Weekend Warrior
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 19 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
Thanksgiving Favorite!
Date:October 23, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, High Quality
This is always a favorite dessert at Thanksgiving for those who are not so crazy about pumpkin pie. Nice alternative!
Blondie
Location: St. Charles, MO
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Family of 3-4
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 20 for Lemon Supreme Pie
Overall Rating
This pie is yummy
Date:October 5, 2010
My family loves this pie! Thank you so much for bringing it back! I've missed it terribly!
Lizzard
Location: Goshen,NY
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
