Shop Now At Market Day
Most Popular Products
Top-Rated Products
Pumpkin Pie
(4)
French Silk Pie
(12)
Customer Reviews for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Apple Deep Dish Pie
The mother of apple pies. Heaping with apples as crispy as the crust is flaky.
Average Customer Rating:
(56 Reviews) 50
Rating Snapshot (56 reviews)
5 stars
47
4 stars
5
3 stars
1
2 stars
2
1 star
1
52 out of 56(93%)customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Review 1 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Apple Deep Dish Pie
Date:January 13, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
This pie was delicious. I am not usually a fan of apple pie but this was great. The crust was fantastic
dano
Location: Moscow, Pa
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 2 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Fantastic!
Date:December 5, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, High Quality, Good Texture
My family and friends love this pie! Better than homemade...I sprinkle a little sugar and cinnamon on top right before baking...absolutely delicious!
schoolnurse2
Location: Chesterton, In
Share this review:
Review 3 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
THE BEST APPLE PIE EVER!!!!!!
Date:November 18, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture, generous portion
This pie is by far the best already-made apple pie I have ever tasted. Well worth the money. Generously sized! A sure crowd-pleaser!
rozz
Location: McMechen, West Virginia
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 4 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
The best ever!!
Date:October 11, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality
This was by far the best apple pie we've bought, we just bought two more for Thanksgiving too.
TheMiddle
Location: Ypsilanti,MI
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 25-34
Share this review:
Review 5 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
No one knows it's not homemade!
Date:February 11, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
This is a perfect apple pie for an apple pie snob. It is the next best thing to homemade. The apples are perfect size, not mushy, not hard, perfect balance of sweet and tart. The crust is flaky and buttery. Don't forget to leave enough time to bake it and let it cool. I have served this for holiday dessert. Crazy delicious!
Torysmom
Location: Cincinnati, OH
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 6 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Best Apple pie
Date:October 12, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
OMG is what i said after trying this pie. It was so delicious, it was gone in no time! Everyone in my household said it was the best pie ever. The crust is delicious and each apple slice is done perfectly. So good, this will be included in my holiday meals from now on!!
lagal
Location: Baltimore, MD
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
0 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 7 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
BEST APPLE PIE BAR NONE!
Date:August 13, 2010
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
This is the BEST apple pie I and my family have ever eaten! The crust is light and flaky and the apple filling is firm and brimming with apples - no mushy filling here. This pie does not last more than a day or 2 at our house. Last Thanksgiving this was the first pie to go!
MEEMAW
Location: Waukesha, WI
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
2 of 3 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 8 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Dairy Free-Apple Pie
Date:May 11, 2012
Pros: Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, Healthy
Be very careful when placing this pie on your table for consumption.............it will surely dissapear before the cook even get a sliver. I guess it's good. I honestly didn't taste it when I put it out for a BBQ during Easter 2012. So, I had to but another w/o guests over. PLUS is that i bought it because it's Dairy Free....now my daughter can enjoy it. She has severe egg/milk/nut allergies. Topped it with some dairy free whipped creme......Looked good! Like i said I didn't get a piece. She enjoyed it. All that mattered.
ZandzsMom
Location: Fort Washington, MD
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 9 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
too much for even an occasional splurge
Date:May 2, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Good Texture
Cons: over the top unhealthy
I have to admit my first thought was that this pie is delicious but they must have really loaded on the butter when they made it..... After the intial yum I started noticing the taste had this full of fat taste hidden in it. I did not feel well after one normal size slice. I won't buy this again. Even as a splurge, I wouldn't feel good feeding this to my family. I don't expect a pie to be low-fat but this was over the top.
scoutmom55
Location: Chicago, IL area
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 10 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
great pie!
Date:May 1, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
The apples are nice and firm. Pie has a great flavor. The crust isn't exactly like "mom's" but its the closet thing you can buy. I'm embarrassed to admit how long the pie sat in our freezer before cooking but it still turned out great. I'm getting ready to order some more.
kookn4boys
Location: Oh
Family: Family of 3-4
Share this review:
Review 11 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Very close to grandmother's pie
Date:April 11, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture
I usually bake my own pies but was in a pich and thought I would try this. Boy was I surprised. I sprinkled a little turbine sugar crystals on top before I baked it and no one new it was not from scratch. I recommend this to everyone to try.
balligo
Location: Oxford, PA
Cooking Style: Health-Conscious
Family: Just the Two of Us
Age: 55-65
Share this review:
Review 12 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Absolutely Scrumptous!
Date:February 28, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile
If you like apple pie you have got to try this pie! It's better than homemade! I was hosting a dinner and made this for dessert and everyone raved over it and wanted the recipe! It just doesn't get any better than this. Well worth every single penny I spent. This pie will be in my cart all the time now.
SusanM
Location: Johnstown, PA
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 13 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Sadly, it's changed!
Date:February 4, 2012
OH, NO! Market Day Apple Pie was my favorite all-time pie... but they have changed the recipe (or the supplier?) since October. The price went up by $1 as well, but that isn't the issue--the crust is NOT good, and neither is the filling. I threw the pie away after eating only a half of a piece. I used to order lots of food from Market Day (JUST so I could get an apple pie!) I haven't ordered from Market Day since the change. As you read the pie reviews, check the date--THE PIE HAS CHANGED.
SuperBusy
Location: Madison, WI
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 14 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Changed the crust
Date:January 25, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep
I have been buying this pie for some time along with the fruit medley pie and I have noticed the crust is not as flaky as it used
to be. I noticed this when I purchased these pies a couple of months ago. Please bring back the old recipe as these pies are
super good and I usually keep more than one in my freezer at a time.
to be. I noticed this when I purchased these pies a couple of months ago. Please bring back the old recipe as these pies are
super good and I usually keep more than one in my freezer at a time.
betsun
Location: Brookfield WI
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: Just the Two of Us
Age: 55-65
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 15 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
One Of My Family's Favorites
Date:January 18, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture
Next to my own homemade apple pies, my kids think this is a close second. I like it because it is tasty, quick and easy.
bdels
Location: Fort Wayne, Indiana
Cooking Style: I Can't Get Out of the Kitchen
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 16 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Awesome pie
Date:January 17, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, High Quality, Good Texture, plump and juicy
I hope they NEVER stop making and selling their apple pies! I couldn't make one this good, honestly. They are the best. Bar none.
Cuzzy
Location: Oakmont, PA
Cooking Style: Gourmet
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 17 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Great Apple Pie
Date:January 8, 2012
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile
When I bake this pie with egg wash on top & sprinkle it with coarse sugar, everyone thinks it's homemade. I like that I can just take it out of the freezer & in an hour, we have hot apple pie. The crust is flaky & the apples have just the right amount of sweetness. I definitely recommend it!
mrsmarketday
Location: Hanover, MI
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: Family of 3-4
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 18 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Date:December 2, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, Easy Prep, Kid-Friendly, High Quality, Good Texture, Versatile
This is the best frozen pie i have ever had!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Harleychick
Location: chicago
Cooking Style: Whatever's Fast
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 45-54
Share this review:
Review 19 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Delicious
Date:November 30, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, High Quality
Do yourself a favor and add this to your holiday dessert menu! Tastes great and what could be easier to prepare?!
wifemometc
Location: Maryland
Cooking Style: Foodie
Family: I've Got a Whole Pack
Age: 35-44
Share this review:
Review 20 for Apple Deep Dish Pie
Overall Rating
Perfect Pie
Date:November 13, 2011
Pros: Flavorful, High Quality, Good Texture
Cons: allow time to prepare
My husband isn't a dessert person and really doesn't eat cake or pie and he loved this. Normal people like it, too. Definitely gourmet and high quality. Can't eat it without vanilla ice cream.
JYNJ
Location: NJ
Share this review:
